Shadowboxing The Object

How might the aggression-releasing benefits of martial arts be understood
psychodynamically and employed psychotherapeutically?

MA Dissertation, Psychodynamic Counselling And Psychotherapy, Goldsmiths, 2023. Awarded 85/100, Outstanding

Abstract

Aggression is central feature of human life yet as a concept it is conflicted, suffering from poor definition and an often negative valuation. This paper explores its positive potentialities for psychotherapy and mental health, reviewing literature on aggression from within and adjacent to psychotherapy with the aim of understanding if and how aggression may be employed beneficially in the work. It further considers literature on trauma recovery, which psychoanalytic theory prefigured, and which increasingly harnesses the body to assist recovery. Martial arts are thought to effect cathartic releases of aggression among participants; thus this paper considers commonalities between psychotherapy and martial arts, and how they might beneficially be combined. It focuses on the martial art of Tai Chi, which I myself practice, arguing that it may offer a sympathetic adjunct to psychotherapy. The paper makes recommendations for practice with clients and for therapists themselves, and for further research.

 Contents

Introduction                                                                                            

Part 1: Three Sentries                                                                               

Part 2: Aggression Versus Violence, plus Sublimation and Body                           

Part 3: Aggression, Martial Arts and Psychotherapy                                             

Part 4: Physicality, Metaphysicality and Metapsychology                                     

Part 5: Limitations, Ethics and Questions for Research                                         

References                                                                               


Introduction: boxers kissing, analysts sitting

A common but often surprising spectacle is that of boxers on TV hugging and kissing their opponents after attempting to dominate one another in a sanctioned performance of aggression. The spectacle might corroborate Freud’s assertion that "hate, as a relation to objects, is older than love" (Freud, 1915a, p.139); after slugging it out in the ring the boxers end up expressing an erotic desire for each another, one all the more surprising since it is always a homosexual attraction. Are, as Bataille suggested in his conceptualisation of eroticism ("our deepest truths come up to consciousness as something accursed and condemned, as sins in fact” [Bataille, 2012, p.163]) the fascinations of loving and fighting, and sex and aggression, two faces of the same coin – magnetically compelling vestiges of an anteceding human?

That people enjoying watching fights, and often not only fight but also feel better for it, raises interesting questions especially when, under civilisation (Freud, 2002) with its Judaeo-Christian moral undergirdings, the by-product of which Freud identified as an often but not solely sexual discontent, aggression is more usually condemned, disavowed, repudiated as obscene, at the least unspeakable – yet remains terminally attractive. Thus this paper considers what other valuation and potentials might be made of aggression and what capacity it has to heal.

Boxers box, often beautifully, and psychotherapists interpret, usually while seated. In the former of these intense dyadic encounters – outside of coitus perhaps the most intense of all possible dyadic encounters – aggression is the sine qua non. In the latter its presence can be more fugitive, yet as those boxers know an invitation to encounter aggression can be life-giving. Releases of aggression are thought to be cathartic, liberating subjects both from social injunctions and their own defences against aggressivity, and in this sense ought to be productive for psychic cohesion, as Mitchell has argued: "If aggression can be experienced within the self and integrated with love and concern, it can be energizing and enriching" (Mitchell, 1998, p.27).

Fighting in martial arts is mediated by the body while psychotherapy is mediated principally by the verbal, and we might ask inter alia what perpetually sedentary therapists might learn about aggression's potential for their clients and themselves. Such is this paper's aim.

Part 1 examines understandings of aggression from theorists including Freud, Winnicott and Lorenz, reviewing definitions of aggression and considering drive theory.

Part 2 reviews further contemporary understandings of aggression and considers sublimation (Freud, 1914). It examines contemporary trauma recovery theory and how the body might be employed as an instrument in psychic recovery.

Part 3 studies martial arts and their relationship with psychotherapy, focusing on Tai Chi and proposing its adjunctive use in therapy.

Part 4 explores metaphysical and metapsychological sympathies between psychoanalysis and Tai Chi's grounding in Taoism.

Part 5 raises ethical and practical issues and questions for further research.

References are included. 

Part 1: Three Sentries

This paper considers what positive valuation and use might be made of aggression and how psychotherapy might at the least address it, and at best productively facilitate its release. An immediate problem rests upon defining what aggression actually is when a fuzziness often prevails, and perhaps nowhere more so than in psychoanalytic discourse where one might naturally expect precision.

For Leider, aggression in psychoanalysis refers to "a myriad of theoretical ideas" including as "an affect, an instinct, or a drive" (Leider, 1998, p.8). For Zuckerman, aggression bridges both human vitality and creativity with malignancy and destructivity (Zuckerman, 2019). Mizen theorises aggression as a relationship to an object involving a trajectory whose conclusion, if carried through, damages or destroys the object; he also offers a helpful separation of aggression from violence – the terms are often clumsily conflated in the literature – by conceptualizing violence as an aggressive response to violation (Mizen, 2009). Further defending the seemingly indefensible, Fonagy argues that some aggression must be considered as survival-oriented and "a genuine protest against hardship in life" (Fonagy, 2003, p.190). This conceptual weather system has many fronts – as many, Mitchell argues, as eskimos have words for snow (Mitchell, 1998).

Psychoanalysis has contended with the phenomenon of aggression but a certain prevarication, summarisable as "is it obscene to say that aggression, like anxiety, might have something good to it?" comes over analytic thought when asked to consider the human characteristic least welcome at dinner parties. Aggression is guarded against, even among psychoanalysts, and when a belief in its release automatically implies the notion of its containment, we may turn to figures who have acted as sentries onto this scary battlefield, and offered contrasting glimpses of it: Freud, Winnicott and Lorenz.

 

 Sigmund Freud, drill sergeant

Reviewing canonical psychoanalytic texts it is tempting to conclude that Freud, while emphasising sexuality as the psyche's imprimatur, was secretly more preoccupied with humankind's aggression, the first clue being less his concepts than his descriptions of them. From the beginning Freud articulated psychoanalysis in the martial (from Mars, the god of war) register of resistance, defence, repression, catharsis and discharge, presenting the psyche in a permanent state of assault and siege wherein forces are blind, surging and belligerent.

We witness the murderous wishes the infant harbours for its parental rival in the Oedipus complex (Freud, 1909b), and the unconscious vendettas masquerading as conscious fears in obsessional neurosis, notably the Rat Man’s patricidal wishes (Freud, 1909a). Far from a rational apparatus, the ego is described a weapon of wanting which “hates, abhors and pursues with intent to destroy all objects which are a source of unpleasurable feeling for it" (Freud, 1915a, p.138), while in melancholia (Freud, 1915 [1917]) the vengeful reproaches destined for the departed other undergo tormenting switchbacks onto the subject’s ego. The superego is also a verbose bully, its energy deriving from the infant's original aggressive fury at parental prohibitions (Freud, 1915b).

In this view Freud's tripartite psyche confronting the reality principle, between which peace only occasionally breaks out, seems less a consensual steering committee and more like those moments when national parliaments descend into brawling, viewable at https://parliamentfights.wordpress.com. One might not reasonably expect a peaceable vision of humankind from the author who memorably wrote that “the aim of all life is death” (Freud, 1920, p.38). Studying Freud's writing, then, the impression is indeed of someone desperately attempting to corral a belligerent horde, "squarebashing" these dynamics into formation – a Von Clausewitz of the psyche.

Freud never defined an aggressive drive per se but detected its presence throughout his writings on drive theory, such as the aggression bound up with self-preservation in his first drive theory, or the hostility operative in the Oedipus complex, described above. His evolving drive theory finally rested in the commingled twin forces of Eros/life drive, and Thanatos/death drive (Freud, 1920), the latter subdivided into one force which causes humans to seek a return to the "absolute repose" (Laplanche & Pontalis, 1988, p.102) of a mineral ataraxia, and another directed externally and which Freud argued accounts for man's destructiveness. Formerly Freud's thought began with libido as a mobile energy obeying the pleasure principle (Freud, 1900); the psyche operated in the opposition between the ego/self-preservative instincts and sexual instincts but aggression was already present in sadism as hate for loved objects and in the sexual self-aggression of masochism. Latterly Freud factored in narcissism (Freud, 1914), where the libido takes the ego as its object, then finally revises his theory into Eros and Thanatos.

Curiously, given widespread ambivalence over this theory, the first portion of the death drive, wanting a return to that "absolute repose" appears less murderously aggressive than its name suggests. Meanwhile, Freud seemed certain that in the ultimate violence against the self it was melancholia's turning of sadism back to the subject's ego, rather than the death drive, which solved "the riddle of the tendency to suicide" (Freud, 1915 [1917], p.252).

Another nuance surrounding analytic ideas on aggression from Freud and after him centres on distinctions between instinct and drive. Instincts for Freud were composed of affects ("any affective state, whether painful or pleasant" [Laplanche & Pontalis, 1988, p.13]) and ideas represented in mental life; drives were originally psychic encrustings upon somatic impulses, "demand[s] made upon the mind for work in consequence of its connection with the body” (Freud, 1915a, p.122). Somatic impulses or instincts refer to "innate, fixed and automatic response[s] to a given stimulus," argue Civitarese and Ferro (Civitarese & Ferro, 2020, p.116).

In this light "aggression" might therefore be either definable as drive, instinct, affect or all three; more convincing is Laplanche & Pontalis' contention that aggression is itself the insistent energy animating all these dynamics: their “inescapable pressure… which activates motricity” (Laplanche & Pontalis, 1988, p.18). For instincts to achieve satisfaction, or drives to achieve their aims action – that "motricity" – must be taken to overcome obstacles in their path.

In his later extemporisings Freud contemplated aggression in philosophical as opposed to solely metapsychological terms. By 1930 it was more broadly an "indestructible feature of human nature”, the tendency for which "it is clearly not easy for people to forgo the satisfaction[s]” (Freud, 2002, p.50). Civilisation heavily taxed these satisfactions as the price of domesticity and sociability, but satisfactions they were, being "linked with an extraordinarily high degree of narcissistic enjoyment" (Freud, 2002, p.57). Moreover, Freud seem resolved that aggression was a "disposition" (Freud, 2002, p.58), and an autonomous, original one at that; perhaps before civilisation, there was only aggression. Still, an analytic term for this thing lacked: "we are without a term analogous to ‘libido’ for describing the energy of the destructive instinct" (Freud, 1940 [1938], p.150).

Writing during and between two world wars and within lethal proximity to continental fascism, Freud's cast of mind was cautious and apprehensive. He had the stomach to enquire on the nastier human parts including hate, sadism, narcissism and the will to power. The notion of "evil", which is one (but only one) manifestation of aggression, is beyond this paper to explore, but Freud saw no possibility of eradicating it: it results from "the deepest essence of human nature [which] consists in instinctual impulses which are of an elementary nature" (Freud, 1915b, p.281).

But perhaps he also saw something in aggression equivalent to the oceanic quality divined by some in love and religious ecstasy (Freud, 2002), but something chthonic, of earth instead of water. When Laplanche and Pontalis write that "there is no kind of behaviour that may not have an aggressive function" (Laplanche & Pontalis, 1988, p.17) they reflect Freud's contention that “the law cannot deal with the subtler manifestations of human aggression” (Freud, 2002, p.49) which are indeed myriad, and not neatly theorizable.

Freud ultimately saw aggression as all-pervasive but also volatile, and while he showed that the twin engines of sexuality and hostility split humans under civilisation, this reading suggests that only aggression split psychoanalysis itself.

Donald Winnicott, boxing coach

Freud's death drive found a sympathetic ear in Klein (Klein, 1991) but it was Winnicott who made the most use of, if not the death drive per se, then its elemental aggressivity. We struggle to find positive applications of aggression in Freudian thought until 1938 when he writes that “holding back aggressiveness is in general unhealthy and leads to illness (to mortification)" (Freud, 1940 [1938], p.150), the misdirections operative in melancholia being only one example.

Winnicott displays no such restraint. Instead he again and again heralds the value of aggression in the service of early-life growth, proposing insights explaining the young person's apparent destructivity. Delinquency for Winnicott is an indicator of health suffering again under prohibitions; the young champ's strength-testing and finding of limits is also a primary course to individuation. So assertively does Winnicott argue for aggression that we might picture him as a boxing coach barking commands from the red corner – an analytic Cus D'Amato to the Mike Tyson of infantility.

Imagine Coach Don later telling the post-match press conference that:

– The kid fights to establish himself against society (the so-called delinquent “…offends against society (without knowing what he is doing) in order to re-establish control from the outside” [Winnicott, 2021a, p.226]).

And:

– He had a tough upbringing, he was depressed; he's in the ring to find his aggression (searching in his delinquency for a pre-traumatic state of security “leads the boy, whenever he feels some sort of hope of a return to security, to rediscover himself, and this means a rediscovery of his own aggressiveness” [Winnicott 1990a, p.95]).

Or that:

– The kid gets depressed BECAUSE he takes responsibility for his fighting (“depression indicates that the individual is accepting responsibility for the aggressive and destructive element in human nature… [he] has a capacity for holding a certain amount of guilt” [Winnicott, 2006, p.86]). Guilt, Winnicott also wrote, is only ever bound up with love (Winnicott, 1990b).

The coach might announce that:

– Fighting, ladeez n gennlemen, makes the kid feel real (reality is constructed by the infant's destructiveness, "plus the object’s survival of the destruction, [which] places the object outside the area of objects set up by the subject’s mental mechanisms. In this way a world of shared reality is created" [Winnicott (2005, p.12])

Coach Don might also quizzically ask:

– Who WOULDN'T want a kid full of spunk? (the normal child "tries out his power to disrupt, to destroy, to frighten, to wear down, to waste, to wangle, and to appropriate” his parents [Winnicott 2021a, p.224])

Winnicott's knowledge was as much paediatric as psychoanalytic and seen this way, aggression is no mere whim but a matter of existential urgency for the infant: he kicks and punches because motility (learning through banging things) is his way of orienting himself ontologically, making reality real. The heart of this motility is, according to Elkins, "movement that is free (uninhibited) to discover the resistance of the world and to press against it" (Elkins, 2015, p.954), like the resistance of an opponent's chin against a boxing glove.

Movement is also "muscle pleasure" (Winnicott, 2021b, p.231) and a primitive subject-object reality is constructed through hitting things because "aggression is always linked in this way with the establishment of a clear distinction between what is the self and what is not the self ” (Winnicott, 2021b, p.232); seen this way, aggression is "an achievement " (Winnicott, 2021b, p.227). Spontaneous fighting in adults – outside the pub on a hot bank holiday, say – arguably reprise these operations, with a violently regressed Subject A articulating to Subject B that "you are not me, therefore I exist" with his fists. And since analysts too were once infants, it also behoves them, Winnicott argued, to reach into their primitive hate and even hate the client in the countertransference, without which no love is possible (Winnicott, 1994).

Winnicott repeatedly valorises aggression, though his preoccupation with it, perhaps like Freud's, sometimes appears overlooked or eclipsed by popularized Winnicottian concepts including the good enough mother and transitional objects. But his thinking also moves beyond both Freud and Klein who prefigured him: Klein's infant seeks nurturance in a theatre of anxiety and through its destructivity comes to understand the need for reparation, thus moving from the paranoid-schizoid to the depressive position (Klein, 1991). The aggression expressed in motility is for Winnicott less to do with security than creativity, and specifically the creation of a self.

While Freud ultimately saw aggression as a component of the death drive, Winnicott conceptualized it as "life force", according to Posner et al. (Posner et al., 2001, p.174), this creativity masquerading as destructivity which brings reality into being, figuring out what is me and not-me: "For Winnicott, without aggression there is no love, and there can be no subject, no object, no reality, and no creativity" (Posner et al., 2001, p.187).

A further key difference is that Winnicott recognised the infant's need for the durability of a maternal boxing ring – the facilitating environment (Winnicott, 1984) – to stage their life-giving, reality-making tantrums. Just as Mike Tyson wouldn't have got far by pulling punches, Winnicott's infant would be condemned to a lacklustre reality without the ruthlessness which the psychoanalyst emphasised, just as analysands' unwillingness to eventually destroy their analysts may consign them to a fruitless and circular analysis. Appraised this way, aggression suddenly appears to have a magical, taproot quality which may be welcomed instead of held captive.

 

Konrad Lorenz, shaman

If aggression represents Freud's great lost theory but was a positive potentiality for Winnicott, the non-psychoanalytic figure of Lorenz fills in some gaps, his analogic studies of intraspecific fighting in animals offering something to analytic theory from beyond it.

Among aggression's functions, Lorenz argued, is species-preservation which is "fulfilled by fights within species" where aggression has a symbolic, acculturative function: "the final, drive-assuaging act… is not the killing of the enemy" but instead "administering a good beating" so that the opponent should "humbly accept my physical, and, if I am to be considered as good as a baboon, my mental superiority" (Lorenz, 2002, p.44). Ironically, aggression also keeps sociality, maintained by rituals and customs to which we are so habituated as to be oblivious, in check, Lorenz argues; recalling Freud's own "subtle manifestations" of aggression, for instance, contravening the social injunction to not pick one's nose in public is tantamount to aggression. In this way, in animals, “an aggression-controlling ceremony can develop into a strong bond comparable to human love and friendship" (Lorenz, 2002, p.74). Indeed “intra-specific aggression can certainly exist without its counterpart, love, but" – once again – "conversely there is no love without aggression” (Lorenz, 2002, p.210).

Meanwhile, as psychoanalysis offers sublimation for absorbing unsatisfied drives, Lorenz offers ethology's comparative of "redirected activity" (“an activity is released by one object but discharged at another" [Lorenz, 2002, p.164]) as an outlet for aggression, a mechanism preventing harm: smashing an expensive object is more socially valuable than destroying the highly aggravating friend who provokes one's wrath, Lorenz argues.

Lorenz also comes to a similar philosophical conclusion to Freud on the problem of humankind under civilisation, namely, what to do with the savage self's vestiges? "According to a useful old psychiatric definition, a psychopath is a man who either suffers himself from the demands of society or else makes society suffer. Thus in one sense we are all psychopaths" (Lorenz, 2002, p.246). Psychopaths in either consulting room chair lose plenty when aggression through moralism or disavowal is eliminated, including “something extremely precious in human life: laughter" (Lorenz, 2002, p.269).

Lorenz was sympathetic to psychoanalytic ideas and shared Freud's humility – ideas such as the death drive were “not inviolable dogmas but… working hypotheses,” he writes (Lorenz, 2002, p.x). He was nevertheless decided that aggression was a drive ranking alongside his other "big drives" of feeding, reproduction and flight, and was assured of its indispensability. This may wound mankind's “spiritual pride"  Lorenz wrote (Lorenz, 2002, p.212), but his aim was not to devolve humans back into beasts, inadvertently justifying evil, but instead to reappraise human aggression by understanding its social value. In this sense he was the shaman of a rewilded human, appealing for contact with this instinctual impulse without which, he argued, the solely rational man "would certainly not be an angel – the opposite" (Lorenz, 2002, p.239). One need only look at fears surrounding the ultimate postmodern rationality – AI – to grasp the argument's logic.


Part 2: Aggression Versus Violence, plus Sublimation and Body

What aggression is not

When, as Fromm (1973) writes, any attempt to find the cause of aggression which includes acts meant to destroy, to protect and to construct (since aggression can have all these functions) puts one in "a theoretically hopeless position" (Fromm, 1973, p.17), we return to the definitional fuzziness where we began. Aggression remains poorly understood and has been conceptualised variously as a drive, an instinct, the energy behind all drives and instincts, a disposition, an animal vestige, a motive of growth, and as something which manifests as variously as picking one's nose in public all the way to international war. In search of further fidelity, this paper now turns to more recent developments in theory.

The semantic fog surrounding aggression also matches one surrounding violence, with which it is often, and lazily, associated. Like aggression, according to Yakeley and Meloy, "Violent behavior is not a generic, homogeneous phenomenon" (Yakeley & Meloy, 2012, p.237). Conflations of aggression and violence are common in psychological literature, along with a pathologisation of aggression: Gillions et al. talk of how "violence and aggression represent a serious problem" (Gillions et al., 2019, p.104); in writing of "treatment for anger or aggression" (Start et al., 2019, p.452) theorists implicitly posit the latter as an illness; psychological literature resorts to jargonisation when violence becomes the euphemistic "externalizing behaviours" (Harwood et al., 2017, p.96).

Conversely, analytic theorists have written lucidly on manifestations of aggression within psychotherapeutic work. For Kradin, the analytic tool of interpretation is already aggressive because it punctures the membrane of narcissism ("As Jung noted, uncovering unconscious contents is a ‘defeat’ for the ego…" (Kradin, 2005, p.432)). Analysts should hold their nerve: not to confront clients' defences would "abandon them to the misery of their neurotic wastelands" (Kradin, 2005, p.443). For Rehm (2013) analysis is automatically aggressive since it entails acts of creative destruction and separations from significant figures requiring the client's self-assertion.

Following a Winnicottian line, Harris argues that an important therapeutic task is to assist clients to own their "right to assertion, to claiming some safety in certain forms of aggression" (Harris, 1998, p.41) and this necessarily entails the therapist's familiarity with their own aggression. Similarly, argues Mitchell (1998), when aggression remains cut off, clients' experience of it will be threatening and persecutory. Raphling (1998) contends that aggression manifests in response to the goal of gaining pleasure – a narcissistic process therefore – which the therapist must expose, simultaneously being aware of their own aggression in the encounter. These understandings, situated in therapeutic practice, helps us more understand aggression more precisely.

Arguments made from a psychoanalytic standpoint (emphasising the unconscious and affect) rather than a psychological one (emphasising consciousness and cognition) not only suggest the value of aggression especially, as Winnicott argued, as a developmental impetus in early life, but also offer a closer understanding of the relationship between aggression and violence.

Mizen privileges subjective experience rather than conscious acts in understanding violence. Commonly considered mindless, violence is only so because it "represents not an absence of mind but rather the ablation [removal of tissue] of mind" (Mizen, 2009, p.417) where the subject is overwhelmed by affective experiences which they are unable to manage through psychological defences. This is not unlike the Kohut's "narcissistic rage" described by Leider which "arises only when the basic fabric of the self has been severely injured" (Leider, 1998, p.16). Violence – verbal or physical – is an evacuating of the powerful affects of violating experiences; more succinctly, "violent acts are attempts not to have aggressive feelings" (Mizen, 2009, p.430).

Yet, Mizen adds, these experiences and the capacity for "aggressive behaviour and aggressive emotional-feelings becomes a necessary and normal part of each individual's biopsychosocial self" (Mizen, 2019, p.116). Integrated into the individual's physical, psychological, social, and cultural situation, they are necessary for "survival, health, safety, and growth". Echoing Lorenz and Winnicott, Mizen adds that "aggression, integrated, is in the service of facilitating these" (Mizen, 2019, p.116).

The ablation of mind which Mizen argues results in violence is articulated by Fonagy as a failure of mentalization. This may result from fractures in early attachment relationships leading to failures to establish "a sense of the other as a psychological entity" (Fonagy, 2003, p.191). For Bateman and Fonagy, mentalization is the process by which "we implicitly and explicitly interpret the actions of ourselves and others as meaningful based on intentional mental states" (Bateman & Fonagy, 2008, p.181). Thus mentalization can theoretically assist in neutralizing the violence primed by experiences of violation.

Meanwhile in sublimation psychoanalysis formulated its own failsafe for excesses of drive, principally sexual ones. Freud's original conception described instincts reoriented towards consolatory parallel aims "other than, and remote from, that of actual satisfaction" (Freud, 1914, p.94), the canvasses typically being artistic creation and intellectual inquiry (Laplanche & Pontalis, 1988).

Yet between an inadequate definition of aggression and an undertheorized notion of sublimation (Laplanche & Pontalis, 1998) which can't account for aggression in any strict sense, we must search further afield. Our inquiry into the value of aggression, held captive by civilisation but perpetually attempting jailbreak, now alights on the question of forms of release – including cathartic, abreactive (Freud, 1893-5) and even orgasmic ones – in a manner somewhat more sensational than Freud's hobbies. As those boxers knew, martial arts are one solution. Beforehand, the animal kingdom beckons again.

Animal Joy

Alsadir's Animal Joy refers not to Lorenz but to Chekhov ("The so-called pure childlike joy is animal joy” [Alsadir, 2022, p.9]) but her narrative refracts our sentries in important ways. Firstly, Lorenz contended that eliminating aggression would abolish laughter too, and Alsadir describes how outbreaks of uncontrollable laughter – technically "Duchenne laughter" such as Freud witnessed when his patient burst out laughing at the funeral (Freud, 1909b) – are moments when the vital aliveness of "animal joy" erupts from its pre-civilised substrate, shattering the moribund conformity of the Winnicottian false self, while also yielding a release of Lacan's jouissance. Humour is aggressive – a joke always needs a butt – and like aggression, laughter wants out and will find its ways. In a further Lorenzian echo, Alsadir valorises the social value of aggression: it can "function like a fire and help maintain the social ecosystem… creating cracks in the walls that divide us" (Alsadir, 2022, p.288).

Secondly, these processes are mediated by the body; in fact they represent a somatic victory over the conscious egoic self, the proof being that as with hiccupping, sneezing or orgasming, we little control over the timing or volume of the emissions. Alsadir writes on her experience of comical mishaps during public speaking, of learning to clown, and of "corpsing" (when stand-up comedians forget their lines) and these instances of psychic nudity illustrate her contention that "we leak truths from our bodies all the time” (Alsadir, 2022, p.96). For Alsadir, these are also forms of parapraxis which reveal the unconscious.

“A spontaneous fit of roaring laughter can, in fact, feel orgasmic," Alsadir writes. "Certain pleasures rub against the edge of pain, whether physical (stitches in your side) or psychological (being transgressive, risking punishment)" (Alsadir, 2022, p.97). Again, laughter as an acceptable if obscene aggression is always directed at something.

Alsadir further makes links between this comically psychotic energy which spontaneously erupts in an unsublimated way, and like Winnicott and Lorenz, argues for a sympathy for it: they represent a “flourishing corporeality, the sensation of being present, alive, embodied” (Alsadir, 2022, p.103). We are in peril when, as with the cataloguing of anxiety as "bad", we deny it. Above all, Alsadir argues, “By numbing aggression, as by suppressing anxiety, you may avoid conflict with those around you, but you will lose access to the taproot, the ability to feel creative, alive, connected to others. By harnessing your living energy – aggressiveness, anxiety, primitive destructive impulses, savage complexity – you can, as McGonigal suggests, 'use some of this biochemistry to make choices to take actions that are consistent with what matters most'" (Alsadir, 2022, p.290).

Joy and aggression are also bodily

This "living energy" might be another way of understanding the character of aggression, and the jouissance of pleasure, pain, obscenity and joy conjured in these eruptions mirror the satisfactions described by those who practice hitting or lifting things, and indeed other forms of psychic jailbreak via embodiment: the biting rawness of sensation in cold-water swimming or getting tattooed. But here the "joy of movement" – reflecting again Winnicott's "muscle pleasure" – is “linked first and foremost to movement, not to fitness,” according to McGonigal (2021, p.3).

This may be why contemporary mental health discourses often centre the body as an instrument of cohesion and recovery, further collapsing the Cartesian split that has ruled medicine for centuries and under which psychoanalysis still toils. In Bell's narrative of overcoming grief and liberation from sizeism, sexism and racism, she writes of a further shade of animal joy accessible through weightlifting. A transcendent state is achieved via deadlifts: "A door opens to a place of serenity… my mind, body and soul are utterly connected in unison" (Bell, 2021, p.25). The enterprise is psychically, even spiritually unifying, but this doesn't preclude aggression; on the contrary, she eulogises "allowing that fury, allowing that rage" (Bell, 2021, p.294). As Zuckerman argues above, a feminist stance encourages women to reappropriate aggression, often but erroneously considered an intrinsically masculine quality.

Khoudari advocates for weightlifting as a method for trauma recovery, a field which is now being studied seriously (Nowakowski-Sims et al., 2023). “Processing trauma is heavy lifting” she writes (Khoudari, 2021, p.89), adding, "I train to deepen my relationship with myself and to feel my capacity for lifting heavy things. I train to be embodied" (Khoudari, 2021, p.8). The training entails muscular activation drills to assist the weightlifter to tap into dissociated body parts.

These discourses locate a cathartic function in somatic practices, substantiating academic research on the symbiosis of exercise for mental health. O’Kelly et al. (1998) and Björkman & Ekblom (2022) find that exercise groups led by psychodynamic practitioners can benefits patients with depression, anxiety states, PTSD, and antisocial behaviour. Hitting things can be cathartic too: Bozdarov et al. (2022) found that non-contact boxing provided a release of anger and stress, while Hefferon et al.'s (2013) study of boxing as an intervention found a strong somatopsychic principle in practice – enhancements in psychological strength via building physical strength.

But not all research is convincing: Hyman and Andres-Hyman's (2013) attempts to apply strength training principles (individuality, specificity, reversibility etc) onto psychotherapy assumes a neat but flawed analogue between psychic and physical functioning; the psychodynamic psyche resists all empirical measurement.

Conversely, exercise can also help clients make meaning, say Crone et al (2005): exercise with a suitably attuned instructor can produce phenomenological or existential outcomes, suggesting a practice gap between exercise and psychological intervention which therapists could fill. It costs around £400 to upskill as a fitness instructor.

 

Aggression for subjects subject to violence

There is a further sense in which theories on bodily mechanisms for releases of aggression are relevant. Research in trauma recovery centres engagement with the body in subjects who have been subject to the trauma of violence and also refers back not only to analytic practice, but to the discipline's birth.

Breuer and Freud's foundational insight was that somatic symptoms (conversions) in hysterics could be treated through cathartically "abreacting" affects after locating their associated hidden memories, the reminiscences from which they famously suffered (Breuer & Freud, 1893-5). The process was primarily verbal, dialogic and, in 1895, hypnotic. A century later protocols on PTSD/C-PTSD recovery remain within this logic but innovation rests upon clinicians' welcoming of the body into the process – the site of harm which then becomes a tool of healing.

In its goal of "waking the tiger" Levine's somatic experiencing has explicitly Lorenzian-Alsadirian tones and is predicated upon reverse-engineering encoded psychosomatic responses that lead to PTSD symptoms. One necessary renegotiation in letting "the body speak its mind" (Levine, 1997, p.62) is directly "to exchange an active, aggressive response for one of being helpless and frozen" (Levine, 1997, p.3).

Like Freud, Levine's approach aims at discharge whereas Ogden's sensorimotor psychotherapy (Ogden & Minton, 2000) eschews this, since discharge may occasion the reexperiencing of trauma. Nonetheless, it too privileges the body as the primary processing site and advances from Gendlin's felt sense (1978) by asking clients to describe physical sensations rather than the emotions attached to them, allowing these to run their course. Mute physical enactments such as clenched fists or pushings-away can be interpreted using these body-oriented approaches.

Meanwhile Herman (2015) sources the history of trauma recovery theory back to Freud, Charcot and Janet, the latter's dissociation as the principal effect of psychic reactions to unbearable traumatic events. PTSD presents with other behavioural and psychic symptoms (hypervigilance, hyperarousal, depression) but trauma is also encoded in the body, in the freeze mode of the fight-flight-freeze response; therapeutic technique must therefore be psychic and verbal, somatic and physical.

The latter of these concern our inquiry most. Herman argues that "the physioneurosis of post-traumatic stress disorder can be modified by physical strategies," suggesting "behavioural techniques, such as relaxation or hard exercise" (Herman, 2015, p.160) including rehabilitating aggression – in short, learning to fight: “By choosing to ‘taste fear’ in… self-defense exercises, survivors put themselves in a position to reconstruct the normal physiological response to danger, to rebuild the ‘action system’ that was shattered and fragmented by their trauma" (Herman, 2015, p.197).

Breuer and Freud wrote that in their dialogic techniques "language serves as a substitute for action" (Breuer & Freud, 1893-5, p.8) yet 120 years later, van der Kolk writes that “traumatic events are almost impossible to put into words” (van der Kolk, 2015, p.231). Theory today suggests that actions can substitute for words, where those clenched fists and pushings-away bespeak what is there beyond the limits of verbal language, the un-symbolisable affect. Movement-based practices, van der Kolk writes, can bring "incomplete, trauma-related 'action tendencies' to completion", leading to the resolution of the trauma (van der Kolk, 2015, p.218). In this way, theorists argue, the body's kinaesthetic "speech" may, once decrypted, be central to recovery from trauma.

Given the above it might seem decided that facilitations of aggression, welcomed and appropriately contained in paracivilised mechanisms and locations (consulting room, gym, boxing club) axiomatically lead to a post-cathartic clarity and mental health. Alas, the picture is less clear.

The popular idea that releases of aggression's emotional codex – anger – are healthy is not without argument (“Healthy anger… is an empowerment and a relaxation. The real experience of anger ‘is physiologic experience without acting out'" [Maté, 2019, p.270]), but one shade of anger (revenge) proves counterproductive. Herman writes that revengers fail to free themselves of PTSD symptoms: "rather, they seem to suffer the most severe and intractable disturbances" (Herman, 2015, p.189), while Carlsmith et al. (2008) also question the method since revengers remain fixated on their assailant. Bushman (2002) similarly found that venting to reduce anger is akin to extinguishing a fire using petrol.

A puzzle thus confronts us: aggression begs expression, and subjects fall ill when it remains suppressed; its release appears to be cathartic, healthy, even joyful. But sublimation might not be enough, and venting perpetuates object-oriented rage. In search of answers this paper now turns eastwards.

 

Part 3. Aggression, Martial Arts and Psychotherapy

East Asian martial arts have been studied variously for their impacts on mental health, their function in respect of aggression, and their interrelationality with psychotherapy, all of which are germane here.

Moore et al. (2002) define martial arts as "any fighting skill acquired through practice" and as with studies below, found they had a positive correlation with mental health. Martial arts are considered an ideal means of acquiring emotional self-control (Lafuente et al., 2021). There is mixed evidence on martial arts' effect on reducing or increasing aggression, but a recurrent characterisation of aggression as negative also pervades literature on martial arts, concurrently with questions over whether training may increase this aggression: regular training can reduce hostility levels (Kostorz & Sas-Nowosielski, 2021) and martial arts practice "that includes internal breathing techniques may ameliorate the external training effects on aggressive motivation and behavior" (Hernandez & Anderson, 2015). Few papers point out that the primary function of martial arts is, by definition, inviting participants' engagement with their aggression. In this sense, martial arts training can produce something which helps loosen the puzzle above.

Researchers (Nosanchuk, 1981; Nosanchuk & MacNeil, 1989) argue that in traditional martial arts trainings aggressiveness falls while in modern trainings with less emphasis on meditation and philosophy it rises. They also describe the Zen state of mushin("no-mind") achievable through practice (Nosanchuk & MacNeil, 1989) in which martial actions can be performed withoutaggressivity. "The Zen trained artist…" they write, quoting the mediaeval Japanese swordsman-philosopher Musashi, "acts only in response to aggression. He does not seek it out… He is a man of peace… When he is pushed, he doesn't push back." This state is achieved "through the ritualization of combat resulting from practicing kata, an opponentless (usually) form of combat training involving a dance-like sequence of attacks and blocks" (Nosanchuk & MacNeil, 1989, p.xxvi).

This understanding of aggression might be compared to mentalization which can recover mind from Mizen's "ablation of mind" (popularly, "mindlessness") as a means of curtailing violence; mushin (no-mind) converts aggression into a nonviolent, intentional or "intent-ful" version of itself. For Rosenberg and Sapochnik this mental state is similar to that of the wellspring of Alsadir's animal joy: “‘no-mind’ could be described as the ability to act and react, in a creative problem-solving way, without being encumbered by thought” (Rosenberg & Sapochnik, 2005, p.452); the “‘no-mind’ concept used here is more akin to Winnicott’s (1960) notion of the spontaneous gestures of the True Self" (Rosenberg & Sapochnik, 2005, p.453).

Fletcher and Milton (2009) further describe this intentional state of mind, achievable though practice, as characterised by calmness and greater control, far from the wild fury implied in "venting". Moreover, identifying the familiar pathologisation of aggression in research with its bias towards deterministic models of aggression to prevent or treat it, these researchers valorise phenomenological and existential approaches to understand its subjective value, especially in the psychotherapeutic context: "What is needed in the therapeutic domain is an understanding of aggression as normal, healthy and appropriate," they write. "Practitioners are not informed of the potential value of aggression for any client and are left considering it pathological, in need of control or removal" (Fletcher & Milton, 2007, p.308). Given these understandings we are newly able to understand the value of aggression-releasing mechanisms in martial arts more lucidly.

This paper is not the first to examine parallels between martial arts and psychotherapy in both technical and functional terms. Martial arts could be a valuable adjunct to therapy since both trainees and psychotherapy clients learn to deal with resistances, and the martial artist's constant, unforced attention towards an opponent mirrors the free-floating attention required of the psychoanalyst, according to Weiser et al (1995). Examining the principles of aikido, another martial art, Saposnek finds parallels in therapy techniques: for instance, aikido's "blending without clashing" principle can translate as the therapist utilising "the client's potential resistance as free energy that he can guide into more beneficial directions” (Saposnek, 1980, p.3). According to Parsons, both disciplines rely on interpreting the other's energies; the psychoanalyst must also act as Herrigel did in his bid to master Zen archery (Herrigel, 2004): "to be able, at the point of highest tension, to do nothing and wait, is just what is required of the psychoanalyst" (Parsons, 1984, p.459). Exploring the analogues between fencing and psychoanalysis are also what enabled Shaw to encounter his own aggression without "acting it out or by falling apart under the weight of denial and repression" (Shaw, 2005, p.99).

Psychotherapy can assist clients in verbally exploring their aggression's phenomenological and existential meanings, while martial arts can do so physically. The therapeutic space and dyadic alliance are for Weiser et al. (1995) a version of the dojo while for Rosenberg and Sapochnik the dojo is an integrative and containing space "like the analytic one – which may act as a reliable container for violence and for fear, and which facilitates a mental and physical form of free association" (Rosenberg & Sapochnik, 2005, p.453). Similarly, as the analysand on the couch discovers "his own shape, the martial arts student is given a structure of movement to inhabit" (Rosenberg & Sapochnik, 2005, p.455).

One logical upshot of these ideas could be conceived as be a synthetic practice of psychodynamic psychotherapy with martial arts, especially, as Twemlow et al (2008) argue, for nonmentalizing individuals resistant to talking therapy and prone to acting out aggression in the "mindless" way described above. A cathecting of body with mind would constitute "a psychoanalytic theory of action" and violent acting out could be "acted on" (Twemlow et al., 2008, p.11) in training rituals.

The many correspondences between psychotherapy and martial arts have been reviewed here. Suggestions for direct application are now presented.

Tai Chi as psychodynamic "martial application"

Psychotherapists appear to know a little about martial arts, though less about the moving body, including their own, and psychoanalysis seems not to have analysed the orthodoxy of sitting, one irony being that psychodynamic work often takes place between two largely static bodies. If the talking cure risks disembodying its clients and practitioners by privileging the verbal and intrapsychic, as therapists collude with clients in "cutting themselves off at the neck," according to Hays (Hays, 1999, p.6), it poses other dangers too: sedentarism is an occupational hazard of therapy, which is “probably the most sedentary job there is" (Coltart, 2021, p.109). Coltart's recommendation of squash to "[steam] off all the suppressed aggression of our daily work" (Coltart, 2021, p.110) is valuable, given that prolonged sitting can even be lethal (Snape, 2023; Chau et al., 2013).

Innovating within psychoanalysis means doing so practically as well as theoretically. According to Ferro and Nicoli, today “analysts have to defend themselves above all from the psychoanalytic… from what we already know" (Ferro & Nicoli, 2017, p.2). The appeal to innovate is implied in Roustang's attacks on the "Dire Mastery" of obedience to analytic doctrine: he may not directly have meant physical puniness but writing on how the "feeble analyst leads to a feeble analysis", Roustang locates the problem among those who consider analytic theory "untouchable, uncriticizable, unsurpassable and who do not question their transference onto the theory" (Roustang, 1976, p.60). The tyranny of the sitting matches the tyranny of an ossified theory base.

Following research on the value of aggression and the moving body as an instrument for psychic cohesion, what then might help clients, therapists and psychotherapy itself get moving, literally as well as figuratively? This paper now examines the nonviolent, opponentless martial art of Tai Chi as an adjunct to psychotherapeutic work, first offering a technical glossary for the reader.

Anglicised spellings: I use the simplified spelling of Tai Chi; others include Tai Chi Chuan, T'ai Chi Ch'uan, Taiji and Taijiquan. Qi-gong is pronounced "chee gung". The terms Qi and Chi, also pronounced "chee", are synonyms used interchangeably in the literature referring to the same original Chinese concept of vital energy (Niles et al., 2022).

Tai Chi: the martial art is often taught in four subsidiary modes: Qi-gong (below); Form (a sequence of stepping movements performed slowly); Pushing Hands (gentle contact practice with a partner) and Martial Applications, where techniques are applied in combat (Mei Quan Academy, n.d.).

Tai Chi was originated by the monk Chang San-Feng in 1200 CE (Liao, 1990) who applied Taoist philosophy to boxing, substituting "pliability for hard-hitting muscular power" (Man-ch'ing, 1981, p.5). Similar to Western shadowboxing, Tai Chi may be thought of as "metaphysical boxing" (Man-ch'ing, 1981, p.xiv); this is explored below. Meanwhile, Grodin et al (2008) point out that even though Tai Chi is not practiced primarily for self-defence, a martial aspect is central to it.

Qi-gong: translating as "energy" (Qi) "work" (gong), Qi-gong involves repetitive movements performed in a stationary standing posture, with breath and movement synchronised. Niles et al (2022) describe the practice as the cultivation or mastery of Qi.

Qi: the Chinese conception of "vital energy and flow of energy in the body, information, breath, or spirit" (Niles et al., 2022). Both Tai Chi and Qi-gong operate by summoning and directing this energy, for the benefit of vigour and health, and against adversaries.

Hard/soft & internal/external martial arts: Tai chi is an “internal/soft" martial art, and its techniques "focus on the flow of energy and the deflection and redirection of the opponent’s energy" (Burke et al., 2007, p.98). Hard/external martial arts styles emphasise explosive, athletic fighting typified according to Liao (1990) by the Shaolin style such as the reader may have seen in the film "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon". Internal/soft styles emphasise the felt and thought over the acted: "All movement begins from deep inside the body and works outwards towards the skin. The object is to completely fuse the inside and outside" (Frantzis, 1998, p.64).

Tai Chi occupies a curious position in the martial arts repertoire since it is grounded in fighting yet is largely practiced in a non-contact manner, absent an opponent, in groups (typically evening classes) or alone, and promoted in the West on its health benefits: flexibility, mindfulness, breathwork etc; benefits less commonly communicated but evidenced by research are listed below. Central to Tai Chi is the learning and practice of a "Form": sequences of stepping movements in which the practitioner mimes fighting techniques including strikes, kicks and deflections, often named after animals: the 24-step Short Form includes such movements as The White Crane Spreads Its Wings and The Snake Creeps Down. Often practiced for health, Tai Chi may also be used in the context for which it was originally formulated for: combat and self-defence. Thus the practitioner is asked to engage their body in fighting movements, "as if" parrying an invisible adversary. The activity encodes into the body and mind fighting movements, writes Frantzis: "As you move your body against imaginary opponents you simultaneously evoke specific psychological states, as you clearly envision the visceral feel of a combat interaction" (Frantzis, 1998, p26). In this sense Tai Chi is firstly a method for encountering one's own aggression.

Meanwhile, research suggests that Tai Chi and Qi-gong can be used as a treatment for a range of disorders which typically concern psychotherapy. Niles et al. (2022) argue that they may be well especially well suited to the treatment of PTSD, as do Grodin et al (2008). Chou et al. describe Tai Chi's positive effects in reducing depressive symptoms (Chou et al., 2004, p.1106) and Hernandez-Reif et al. (2001) describe how Tai Chi practice can reduce anxiety and hyperactivity in children with ADHD. Typically performed mindfully and attentively, it emphasizes "close association between consciousness, breath and action… [and] can serve as an auxiliary therapy for depression, anxiety and other neuroses" (Zheng et al., 2015, p.175).

The martial art's benefits, say Solloway et al., span the somatic and the psychological with a "potentially positive [italics mine] treatment effect on patient outcomes, including… for hypertension, fall prevention, cognitive performance, osteoarthritis, depression, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, pain, balance confidence, and muscle strength" (Solloway et al., 2016, p.1). Research shows that as a "somatosensory attentional training practice", Tai Chi even improves tactile acuity (Kerr et al., 2008, p.321).

Having perhaps observed Tai Chi being practiced the reader will know that it is performed at a languid pace markedly different from the furious velocity of, say, Western boxing or Japanese karate; yet therapists at risk of death-by-sitting, as well as clients, may be intrigued to learn that Tai Chi is comparable to moderate exercise, reducing tension, depression, anger, fatigue, confusion and state-anxiety and producing enhancements in vigour, according to Jin (1989). Tai Chi practice incorporates key principles of modern exercise training – cardiorespiratory function, strength, balance and flexibility (Lan et al., 2002). Physical fitness is today measured against five indices – cardiovascular fitness, muscular strength, muscular endurance, flexibility, and motor fitness (Coulson, 2021); Tai Chi practice incorporates three of these.

These learnings present evident appeal for therapists and their clientele, yet they may not be well known publicly; like psychoanalysis, Tai Chi suffers from a certain mystification. Conversely, the martial art also fits the mould of the Movement-Based Embodied Contemplative Practice (MECP), described by Schmalzl et al. (2014). Practiced outside of the dyad it is plausibly also an effective "technology of the self" (Foucault, 1988) or method of "ascesis" – a practice to engage with the self to go beyond the self – as Halperin (1997, p.79) has written.

As an MECP, a technology of the self or otherwise Tai Chi appears as a natural complement to psychotherapy. But there is a more precise sense in which Tai Chi may prove valuable in the re-evaluation of aggression in psychotherapy.

Suggestions for practice

Tai Chi's classification as one of China's "folk arts" (Liao, 1990, p.ix) qualifies it as a method for and product of sublimation but it also may be argued that Tai Chi offers an intriguing twist on the encounter with aggression. Meanwhile, summarising the explorations above we might here consider a range of modes of aggression, constructing a novel but useful taxonomy.

First, if "passive aggression" exists (being "passive aggressive" by making backhanded compliments or damning someone with faint praise) it necessarily begs the concept of "active" or "aggressive aggression" – that which is facilitated in boxing.

Then, weightlifting for trauma recovery, above, and popular contemporary activities such as cold-water swimming, tattooing and body modification suggest the possibility of "adhesive aggression" after Bick (Bick, 1968), in which subjects "glue" symbolisations of aggression to their skin, in so doing enjoying cathartic sensations of biting embodiment.

In this taxonomy, mindless aggression is what we know of as violence (nonmentalized aggression); this leads us to the "aggressive passivity" of mushin/no-mind.

This is relevant because hard/external martial arts such as boxing either 1: return aggression from sublimation into enacted motor expression; or 2: socialise "aggressive aggression" into the sanctioned and relatively safe activities of sparring and padwork.

However, Tai Chi operates differently: in its mimed fighting movements it resublimates aggression into an intentional yet nonviolent parallel version of its original self: an artistic "dream fighting" which doesn't disavow the practitioner's aggression – in fact welcomes it – but prevents them from being overwhelmed by it or hurting anyone else, simultaneously enabling them to mentalize it in precisely configured movements which themselves act as containers.

Tai Chi's gentle pace warrants the descriptor "dreamlike" and this is not the only overlap with the psychic activity. Winnicott postulated dreaming as an alternative to aggressive behaviour in children, and suggested that play based "on the acceptance of symbols has infinite possibilities in it. It enables the child to experience whatever is to be found in his or her personal inner psychic reality" (Winnicott, 2021b, p.234). Such symbols in children's play are often animals, and recalling Tai Chi's white crane and creeping snake, Tai Chi might thus be considered not merely as "play fighting" but also as a re-dreamt aggression – a directly psychic activity.

Tai Chi practice may thus enable clients and therapists to encounter their own often disavowed or denied aggression in highly codified yet entirely safe movements. In the repetition of punches, kicks and deflections against an imaginary opponent it could also offer to traumatised or angry clients struggling with a suppressed wish to strike back or push away, a method for doing so psychically or imaginatively yet also physically and nonviolently, recruiting both mind and body: shadowboxing the object.

If this seems far-fetched a description of a specific Tai Chi movement may help. The movement Grasp Sparrow's Tail is easily learnable in, say, 10 minutes of instruction, and can be practiced as a flowing, turbine-like Qi-gong sequence. The author demonstrates this at

https://youtu.be/cV2JbOFo69k

The sequence contains Tai Chi's "four powers" – primary fighting movements – of Peng (Ward Off), Lu (Roll Back), Ji (Press) and An (Push), described here with analysis from Frantzis (1998):

Peng (Ward Off)

A lifting, pushing motion where the practitioner holds an arm across the chest, as if carrying a shield. "Peng refers to energy rising or expanding from its source… it is equally defensive and attack oriented in nature" (Frantzis, 1998, p.127).

 Lu (Roll Back)

A pulling, yielding motion where the practitioner shifts their weight backwards while bringing the palms together near the hip. "Lu refers to the ability to energetically absorb and/or yield to counter an incoming force " (Frantzis, 1998, p.128).

Ji (Press)

A pressing-away motion made with the back of one wrist and the palm of the other hand, as the practitioner shifts their weight forward. "This internal energy projects forwards from its source, on a straight line… It is the primary attack technique in tai chi" (Frantzis, 1998, p.134).

An (Push)

A downward pushing motion. According to Frantzis, "it can cause an attacking man's centre of gravity to be energetically forced to the ground " (Frantzis, 1998, p.135).

Unusual to observe or learn, these fighting movements when practiced diligently may inscribe in the practitioner's mind and body a syntax of attack and defence: strikings, pulling-overs, pressing-aways, pushing-downs – physical articulations of hitherto unmentalized impulses or wishes. It may not be possible to overwrite the unconscious but in this way developments in the conscious system can be made: Schmalzl et al. also write that Qi-gong practice often progresses from large and overt to small and subtle movements, to purely internal or imagined ones. These "subtle movement[s] may have the effect of reprogramming counterproductive patterns of intention and action by bringing the process of initiating action up to full consciousness" (Schmalzl et al., 2014, p.2). As an "'internal martial art' movements are made both while visualizing and feeling an imaginary opponent," writes Frantzis (1998, p.81).

Both Herman and van der Kolk have written on the value of this kind of encounter in the service of trauma recovery: Herman talks of self-defence exercises to "reconstruct the normal physiological response to danger, to rebuild the ‘action system’ that was shattered and fragmented by their trauma" (Herman, 2015, p.197), while van der Kolk argues that upon eventual toleration of their trauma-based physical experiences patients "are likely to discover powerful physical impulses – like hitting, pushing or running – that arose during the trauma but were suppressed in order to survive" (van der Kolk, 2015, p.218) – movements which the "four powers" above articulate.

When van der Kolk also writes about a mugging programme in which patients rehearse fighting off an assailant, thereby learning to transform fear into "positive fighting energy" (van der Kolk, 2015, 218), it is almost as if San-Feng – a psychoanalytic thinker 700 years before the discipline's invention – understood a human need.

In this sense Tai Chi may be understood as a fighting system but also as a processing system for whatever it is that amounts to Herman's "normal physiological response" to threat, intrusion or violation, and conceivably for the hauntings of an undead response to the other's traumatising violence. In Tai Chi clients may thus be able to encounter their aggression, re-dream it and constructively yet harmlessly enact it – waking the tiger. Sublimated into an art of movement, their aggression is rehabilitated while its power to harm the self or the other – its violence – is neutralised.

Part 4: Physicality, Metaphysicality & Metapsychology

There are further ways in which Tai Chi and psychotherapy, emphatically Eastern and Western disciplines respectively, may elucidate one another. First, a caution: there remains a risk of misinterpretation when concepts from one framework are transcribed into another foreign to it – here, a practice grounded in an Eastern philosophy (Taoism) understood through Western science. As Schmalzl et al have written, "Our task is one of translation," namely of "theories emerging from one worldview into a language based on a very different world-view" (Schmalzl et al., 2014, p.4). Other researchers issue similar warnings against positivising such practices as Tai Chi, but there is an alternative method for translation, even synthesis. Understanding Eastern styles of thought such as Taoism and Zen lends itself less to positivism than to phenomenology: this "context-sensitive approach… might clarify the contextual intricacy of the martial arts" (Columbus & Rice, 1991, p.127). Like yoga, 12-step recovery or indeed psychoanalysis, these practices can perhaps only really be grasped through the experience of them – ie, subjectively or phenomenologically.

Ironically, this translational problem challenged Freud's petitions for psychoanalysis to be accepted as a science of the unconscious, and Lacan's attempts to distinguish psychoanalysis through the matheme. Their failures in doing so were arguably what kept the discipline alive, permitting it to expand rhizomatically and resist scientification under the "Dire mastery" of its sovereign pioneers. Nonetheless, Tai chi and psychotherapy have yet more in common, metaphysically and metapsychologically.

Scholars of Tai Chi share a vision of the human that psychotherapy, or at least Freud and Winnicott, described. On how to contend with a seemingly innate aggression Liao writes that "we may come to realize that we fundamentally have not progressed very far from the original inhabitants of this planet” (Liao, 2002, p.4), an outlook not so far from Freud's gloomy determinism: savagery remains barely hidden under the veneer of civilisation, and Freud's balkanized psyche is more often a brawling parliament than a peaceable assembly.

Writing from an existentialist-humanist viewpoint, Fromm disparaged Lorenz for suggesting that the animal is alive in the human; but it was for this profane idea precisely that Freudian thought was and remains repudiated by some. A resolute protagonist of Enlightenment rationality, according to Gray (2011), Freud nevertheless revealed to the Enlightenment its limits, with the unconscious as the demilitarized zone of reason. His weltanschauung "is condemned as a kind of slander on the species, the fundamental nobility of which it is sacrilege to deny", writes Gray (2011); Freud's ideas were rejected for suggesting that human being themselves are the source of disorder (Gray, 2011). Lao-Tzu and San-Feng surely intuited this too.

Freud was finally puzzled that aggression had evaded serious conceptual rigour in the analytic project (Freud, 2002); it fell to Winnicott to later argue for a new valuation of aggression – a sympathy for the devil – as a developmental necessity. Their shared goal was to venture wherever necessary, through sex, obsession, death and madness to assist patients to restore health from neurosis: a saintly mission indeed. Yet oddly enough, the BACP's "Personal Moral Qualities" (BACP, 2023) could have been written by a Taoist: followers of Tai Chi, writes Liao, "should discipline themselves to be spiritual, healthy, kind, and intelligent; to be responsible for assisting others to reach the same levels of achievement; to enjoy the truth" (Liao, 2002, p.12).

A sympathy for aggression is shared by all martial artists but only some psychotherapists, ones who refuse to disavow or prettify it, and pull the gloves on instead. More should take an interest: Frantzis describes fighting "as a way to become an evolved being" (Frantzis, 1998, p.5).

Ancient and modern theorists of fighting share something with figures including Watts for whom psychoanalysis is merely a modern remedy for a timeless problem, that of the unconscious. According to Watts ancient paths including Taoism had already solved the problem of the deadlock between loving and hating, and this amounted to "the art of living with one’s gods and demons" (Watts, 2003, p.96), internal forces manifested in Christianity as God and the devil and which Freud transfigured into Eros and Thanatos. The strategy, Watts argues, changed from the antique imperative to "know thyself" to the modern rationalist "rule thyself" (Watts, 2003, p.96). Thus, “the idea of the unconscious… was simply man’s fumbling rediscovery of the lost gods and demons” (Watts, 2003, p.97). Like Lorenz, Taoism seemingly understood that the urge to fight was innate in humans, and in Tai Chi formulated a methods to contend with it.

Centuries hence, human nature still appears to wish both to cohere and split apart: Kalsched has written on the roots of "diabolic", often closely associated with the evil of violence, and he analyses the word's Greek etymology to discover dia (across) and ballein (to throw), a force of tearing apart opposing symbolic, sym-ballein (throwing together), a striving towards unity (Kalsched, 1996). Recalling that Freud characterised the repetition compulsion as a daemonic force (Freud, 1915b), we might imagine Watts looking on knowingly as our enquiry finally reenters the dialectic.

The binary of Eros and Thanatos in Freud's final drive theory has a parallel in Yin and Yang, Taoism's governing duality: entities opposed yet inseparable and generative of one another. The unified symbol, enclosed in a circle, is in fact known not as Yin-Yang but "Tai Chi" according to Watts (Watts, 2000). A deeper discussion of Yin and Yang is beyond this paper but it remains to say that Taoism glosses neither as "good" or "bad". Freud evaluated Thanatos more cautiously than Eros but thought both had their purposes. Modern thinkers struggle to locate the roots and uses of aggression, often evaluating it in pre-Nietzschean, good-or-evil terms. They may be wiser to adopt the Taoist perspective that aggression simply is.

Aggression may seem a function of Freud's "diabolical" Thanatos but we might finally ask if Eros and Thanatos, the erotic and the aggressive/destructive, are not mutually exclusive but more like Yin and Yang: commingled and inseparable, defying logical understanding. If the erotic has something aggressive to it (after all, cardiovascular fitness, strength and endurance are required in lovemaking; assertion is required in asking someone out for a drink) then there is surely something of the erotic in the aggressive, as the boxers with whom this paper began know. This is to suggest a final, nuanced but ultimately fluid evaluation of aggression, one which is open to many interpretations and which respects its potential for harm but equally its potential for growth and life, especially in psychotherapy.

When Man-Ch'ing talks of "something invisible" (Man-Ch'ing, 1981, p.87) animating Tai Chi, he refers to the Chi which has been defined variously as "the source of creativity, the vital fullness of life…" (Seitz et al, 1990) and as "'power', 'motion, 'energy', or 'life'" and "'intrinsic energy'" (Liao, 2002, p.18). Tai Chi raises and manifests this Chi – an energy for, about, towards living, including fighting – while psychoanalysis tracks the libido's cathexes. In this talk of invisible yet tangible energies, then, how far is Chi really from Freud's libido and its later incarnation in Eros, the life drive, as it dances inseparably with its Thanatic partner?

Freud had heard of yoga; as far as we know he didn't practice Tai Chi.

Part 5: Limitations, Ethics and Questions for Research

The author has not attempted to introduce these ideas into practice. His interest has been led variously by a curiosity over clients' disavowal, defences against, or outright horror at their own aggression towards internal and external objects, and his productive encounters with his own aggression in Tai Chi and embodied modalities including running and weightlifting. As it is this paper's conclusions raise both practical and ethical issues warranting further research.  

Continually cognisant of the primum non nocere principle in clinical work, especially where the volatility of aggression is concerned, exercise nevertheless has a history in psychoanalysis. Freud conducted analyses while hiking (Hays, 1999), and dyadic walking therapy is an established practice today (Pollock & Pullen, n.d.). The coupling of exercise and psychotherapy has a "synergistic potential" (Hays, 1999, p.59) and "a multimodal approach, in which exercise is encouraged in conjunction with psychotherapy, may offer greater success than either intervention used alone", writes Hays (1999, p.14). Further, pairing psychotherapy with Tai Chi is conceivable in two ways Hays formulates: as adjunctive to psychotherapy (an add-on activity to enhance the work in terms of the health benefits above) and as a medium for psychotherapy (exercise, like dancing or art, to facilitate client expression) (Hays, 1999).

In the latter regard Hays lists five valuable potentialities, some of which have already been illuminated here: in the client, clarity of thinking and capacity to synthesise in new ways; shifts in cognition; the shift to physical expression; the possibility for therapists to gain information from clients non-verbally; and increased activity and body awareness which could be the locus for flashbacks or body memories (Hays, 1999), and therefore productions for therapists to offer interpretations upon. Theoretically these map onto the suggestions made earlier.

Nevertheless, this paper's suggestions are remote from orthodox psychodynamic practice and while there is some literature on combining fighting-based modalities with psychotherapy, there is little evidence of theory being implemented in practice. The suggestions made above may amount to directivity, which is frowned upon, and the therapist-as-sensei may indeed find it difficult to model Freud's surgeon-like attitude (Freud, 1912). Any such interventions would also occasion a radical change in the nature of the interaction between client and therapist. At the minimum therefore, therapists need to examine issues including "boundaries, intimacy, competition, dual role relationships… dependency, eroticization, and power" (Hays, 1999, p.65).

Therapists must also guard against their wishing /projections to get a stuck patient unstuck, enacting their own rather than their client's desire; and to rigorously examine their own countertransference in this regard. As a further minimum therapists would need elementary training in Tai Chi to apply this paper's suggestion but as argued this would also mitigate their risk of death-by-sitting.

 

References

Alsadir, N. (2022). Animal Joy. Fitzcarraldo

BACP (n.d.). Ethical framework for the counselling professions. https://www.bacp.co.uk/events-and- resources/ethics-and-standards/ethical-framework-for-the-counselling-professions/

Bataille, G. (2012). Eroticism. Penguin

Bateman, A. & Fonagy, P. (2008). Comorbid antisocial and borderline personality disorders:    mentalization-based treatment. Journal Of Clinical Psychology: In Session, 64(2), 181-194         DOI: 10.1002/jclp.20451

Bell, P. (2021). Stronger. Changing Everything I Knew About Women’s Strength. Bluebird

Bick, E. (1968). The experience of the skin in early object relations. International Journal of     Psychoanalysis, 49, 484.

Björkman, F. & Ekblom, O. (2022). Physical Exercise as Treatment for PTSD: A Systematic         Review and Meta-Analysis.Military Medicine 187 (9/10).

Bozdarov J., Jones B.D.M., Daskalakis Z.J., & Husain M.I. (2022). Boxing as an Intervention in    Mental Health: A Scoping Review. American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine. 0(0).      doi:10.1177/15598276221124095

Burke, D. T., Al-Adawi, S., Lee, Y.T., & Audette, J. (2007). Martial arts as sport and therapy.      Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness, 47(1).

Bushman, B. J. (2002). Does Venting Anger Feed or Extinguish the Flame? Catharsis, Rumination,      Distraction, Anger, and Aggressive Responding. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin   28(6), 724-731.

Carlsmith, K.M., Wilson, T.D., & Gilbert, D.T. (2008). The Paradoxical Consequences of Revenge.       Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95 6), 1316–1324. DOI: 10.1037/a0012165

Chau, J.Y., Grunseit, A.C., Chey, T., Stamatakis, E., Brown, W.J., Matthews, C.E., Bauman, A.E., & van der Ploeg, H.P. (2013). Daily Sitting Time and All-Cause Mortality: a Meta-Analysis. PLoS        One. 8(11): e80000. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0080000.

Chou, K., Lee, P.W.H., Yu E.C.S., Macfarlane, D., Cheng, Y., Cha, S.S.C., & Chi, I. (2004). Effect of Tai    Chi on depressive symptoms amongst Chinese older patients with depressive disorders: a randomized clinical trial. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 19, 1105–1107.

Civitarese, G. & Ferro, A. (2020). A Short Introduction To Psychoanalysis. Routledge

Coltart, N. (2021). How To Survive As A Psychotherapist. Phoenix

Columbus, P.J. & Rice, D.L. (1991). Psychological research on the martial arts: An addendum to         Fuller’s review. British Journal of Medical Psychology 64, 127-135.

Coulson, M. (2021). The Fitness Instructor's Handbook 4th edition (Fitness Professionals).        Bloomsbury Sport

Crone, D., Smith, A., & Gough, B. (2005). ‘I feel totally at one, totally alive and totally happy’: a         psycho-social explanation of the physical activity and mental health relationship. Health     Education Research. Theory & Practice, 20(5), 600–611.

Elkins, J. (2015) Motility, Aggression, and the Bodily I: an Interpretation of Winnicott. The       Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 84(4), 943-973, DOI: 10.1002/psaq.12044

Ferro, A., & Nicoli, L. (2017). The New Analyst’s Guide To The Galaxy. Routledge

Fletcher, R., & Milton, M. (2007). An Existential-Phenomenological Critique of the         Psychological Literature on Human Aggression. Existential Analysis 18(2).

Fletcher, R., & Milton, M. (2009). An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of Kung Fu      Practitioners’ Experience of Aggression. Existential Analysis 20(1).

Fonagy, P. (2003). Towards a developmental understanding of violence. British Journal of       Psychiatry, 183, 190-192.

Foucault, M. (1988). Technologies of the Self. A Seminar with Michel Foucault. Tavistock Publications

Frantzis, B. K. (1998). The Power of Internal Martial Arts. Combat Secrets of Ba Gua, Tai Chi and        Hsing-i. North Atlantic

Freud, S. (1893-1895). On the psychical mechanism of hysterical phenomena: preliminary        communication. The Standard Edition of The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund        Freud, Volume II, pp.1-17. Translated by James Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1900). The interpretation of dreams. The Standard Edition of The Complete    Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume IV. Translated by James Strachey. The       Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1909a). Notes upon a case of obsessional neurosis. The Standard Edition of The        Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume X, pp.152-318. Translated by        James Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1909b). Analysis of a phobia in a 5-year-old boy. The Standard Edition of The Complete     Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume X, pp.1-149. Translated by James Strachey.    The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1912). Recommendations to physicians practicing psycho-analysis. The Standard      Edition of The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XII, pp.109-120. Translated by James Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1914). On narcissism: an introduction. The Standard Edition of The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XIV, pp.67-107. Translated by James       Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1915a). Instincts and their vicissitudes. The Standard Edition of The Complete          Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XIV, pp.109-140. Translated by James         Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1915b). Thoughts for the times on war and death. The Standard Edition of The         Complete    Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XIV, pp.273-302. Translated by James          Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1915 [1917]). Mourning and melancholia. The Standard Edition of The Complete      Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XIV, pp.237-258. Translated by James         Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1920). Beyond the pleasure principle. The Standard Edition of The Complete   Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XVIII, pp.1-64. Translated by James Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (1940 [1938]. An outline of psychoanalysis. The Standard Edition of The Complete     Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Volume XXIII, pp.148-151. Translated by James         Strachey. The Hogarth Press

Freud, S. (2002). Civilisation and its Discontents. Penguin

Fromm, E. (1973). The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness. Penguin

Gendlin, E. (1978). Focusing. Bantam

Gillions, A., Cheang, R., & Duarte, R. (2019). The effect of mindfulness practice on aggression and     violence levels in adults: A systematic review. Aggression and Violent Behavior 48, 104–115.

Gray, J.N. (2011). Freud: the last great Enlightenment Thinker. https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/culture/49771/freud-the-last-great-enlightenment-         thinker

Grodin, M.A., Piwowarczyk, L., Fulker, D., Bazazi, A.R., & Saper, R.B. (2008). Treating survivors of      torture and refugee trauma: a preliminary case series using qigong and t’ai chi. The    Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 14(7), 801–806.

Halperin, D.M., (1995). Saint Foucault. Towards a Gay Hagiography. Oxford University Press

Harris, A. (1998). Aggression: pleasures and dangers. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 18(1), 31-44, DOI: 10.1080/07351699809534168

Harwood, A., Lavidor, M., & Rassovsky, Y. (2017). Reducing aggression with martial arts: A meta-      analysis of child and youth studies. Aggression and Violent Behavior 34, 96–101.    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2017.03.001

Hays, K.F. (1995). Putting sport psychology into (your) practice. Professional Psychology:         Research     and Practice 1995, 26(1), 33-40.

Hays, K.F. (1999). Working It Out: Using Exercise In Psychotherapy. American Psychological     Association

Hefferon, K., Mallery, R., Gay, C., & Elliott, E. (2013). ‘Leave all the troubles of the outside world’:     a qualitative study on the binary benefits of ‘Boxercise’ for individuals with mental health      difficulties. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 5(1), 80-102, DOI: 10.1080/2159676X.2012.712995

Herman, J. (2015). Trauma and Recovery. Basic

Hernandez, J., & Anderson, K.B. (2015). Internal martial arts training and the reduction of       hostility and aggression in martial arts students. Psi Chi Journal of Psychological Research         20(3).

Hernandez-Reif, M., Field, T.M., & Thimas, E. (2001). Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: benefits from tai chi. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 5(2), 120-123.

Herrigel, E. (2004). Zen in Art of Archery. Penguin

Hyman, S.M. & Andres-Hyman, R.C. (2013). A strength-based exercise training model of          psychotherapy: can principles derived from exercise and sport physiology guide behavioral     prescriptions for physical and mental wellness? American Journal Of Psychotherapy, 67(4),     2013.

Jin, P. (1989). Changes in heart rate, noradrenaline, cortisol and mood during tai chi. Journal of        Psychosomatic Research, 33(2), 197-206.

Laplanche, J. & Pontalis, J-B. (1988). The Language of Psychoanalysis. Karnac

Leider, R.J. (1998). In the belly of the beast: the vicissitudes of aggression. Psychoanalytic       Inquiry, 18(1), 8-20. DOI: 10.1080/07351699809534166

Kalsched, J. (1996). The Inner World of Trauma. Archetypal Defences of the Human Spirit. Routledge

Kerr, C.E., Shaw, J.R., Wasserman, R.H,. Chen, V.W., Kanojia, A., Bayer, T., & Kelley, J.M. (2008).        Tactile acuity in experienced tai chi practitioners: evidence for use dependent plasticity as     an effect of sensory-attentional training. Experimental Brain Research 188, 317–322. DOI        10.1007/s00221-008-1409-6

Khoudari, L. (2021). Lifting Heavy Things. Lifetree

Klein, M. (1991). Notes on some schizoid mechanisms. In Mitchell, J. (Ed.) The Selected Melanie Klein          Reader. Penguin

Kostorz, K., & Sas-Nowosielski, K. (2021). Aggression dimensions among athletes practising     martial arts and combat sports. Frontiers in Psycholog,y 112. DOI:   10.3389/fpsyg.2021.696943

Kradin, R. (2005). The roots of empathy and aggression in analysis. Journal of Analytical Psychology, 50, 431-449.

Lan, C., Lai, J., & Chen, S.Y. (2002). Tai chi chuan: an ancient wisdom on exercise and health    Promotion. Sports Medicine32(4): 217-224. DOI: 0112-1642/02/0004-0217/$25.00/0

Lafuente, J.C., Zubiaur, M., & Gutierrez-García, C. (2021). Effects of martial arts and combat    sports training on anger and aggression: A systematic review. Aggression and Violent   Behavior 58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2021.101611

Levine, P. (1997). Waking The Tiger. Healing Trauma. North Atlantic

Liao, W. (1990). T’ai chi Classics. Shambhala

Lorenz, K. (2002). On Aggression. Routledge

Man-ch’ing, C., (1981). T’ai chi ch’uan. A Simplified Method of Calisthenics for Health & Self     Defense. North Atlantic

Maté, G. (2019). When The Body Says No. Vermilion

McGonigal, K. (2021). The Joy of Movement. Avery

Mei Quan Academy (n.d.). About Tai Chi. https://taichinews.com/about-taichi

Mitchell, S.A. (1998). Aggression and the endangered self. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 18(1), 21-30,        DOI: 10.1080/07351699809534167

Mizen, R. (2009). The so-called mindlessness of violence: violence as a pathological variant of aggression. Global Crime, 10(4), 416-431, DOI: 10.1080/17440570903248494

Mizen, R. (2019). The affective basis of violence. Infant Mental Health Journal. 40, 113-128. DOI:      10.1002/imhj.21755

Moore, B., Dudley, D., & Woodcock, S. (2020). The effect of martial arts training on mental     health outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Bodywork & Movement      Therapies, 24, 402-412.

Niles, B.L., Reid, K.F., Whitworth, J.W., Alligood, E., Williston, S.K., Grossman, D.H., McQuade, M.M,. & Mori, D.L. Tai chi and qigong for trauma exposed populations: a systematic         review. Mental Health and Physical Activity, 22.    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mhpa.2022.100449

Nosanchuk, T.A. (1981). The way of the warrior: the effects of traditional martial arts training on      aggressiveness. Human Relations, 34(6), 435-444.

Nosanchuk, T.A. & MacNeil, M.L.C. (1989). Examination of the effects of traditional and modern       martial arts training on aggressiveness. Aggressive Behaviour 15, 153-159.

Nowakowski-Sims, E., Rooney, M., Vigue, D., & Woods, S. (2023). A grounded theory of weight lifting         as a healing strategy for trauma. Mental Health and Physical Activity, 25.       doi.org/10.1016/j.mhpa.2023.100521.

Ogden, P., & Minton, K. (2000). Sensorimotor psychotherapy: one method for processing       traumatic memory. Traumatology, 3(3).

O’Kelly, JG., Piper W.E., Kerber, R., & Fowler, J. (1998). Exercise groups in an insight-oriented, evening treatment program. International Journal of Group Psychotherapy, 48(1), 85-98.    DOI: 10.1080/00207284.1998.11491523

Parsons, M. (1984). Psychoanalysis as vocation and martial art. International Review of Psychoanalysis, 11.

Pollock, K., & Pullen, W. (n.d.). Outdoor therapy. https://www.bacp.co.uk/about- therapy/outdoor-therapy

Posner, B. M., Glickman, R.W., Taylor, E.C., Canfield, J., & Cyr, F. (2001) In Search of Winnicott's        Aggression. The Psychoanalytic Study of The Child, 56(1), 171-190.
         DOI: 10.1080/00797308.2001.11800672

Raphling, D.L. (1998). The narcissistic basis of aggression. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 18(1), 100-106.
         DOI: 10.1080/07351699809534174

Rehm, R. (2013). Meditations on aggression, loss, discovery, and influence in psychoanalysis.  Psychoanalytic Dialogues, 23(5), 528-541. DOI: 10.1080/10481885.2013.832593

Rosenberg, V., & Carlos Sapochnik, C. (2005). Martial arts – enactment of aggression or integrative   space? Psychodynamic Practice 11(4), 451-458. DOI:10.1080/14753630500385681

Roustang, F. (1976). Dire Mastery. American Psychiatric Press

Saposnek, D.T. (1980). Aikido: a model for brief strategic therapy. Family Process 19, 227-238.          doi.org/10.1111/j.1545-5300.1980.00227.x

Schmalzl, L., Crane-Godrea, M.A., & Payn, P. (2014). Movement-based embodied contemplative practices: definitions and paradigms. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 8, 205.

Seitz, F.C., Olson, G.D., Locke, B., & Quam, R,. (1990). The martial arts and mental health: the challenge of managing energy.Perceptual and Motor Skills, 70.

Shaw, G. (2005). Facing Aggression in the Pedgogical Relationship. Lessons from Fencing and Psychoanalysis. Journal of Curriculum Theorizing, 21.

Snape, J. (2023, May 14). Should I worry about how long I spend sitting down?      https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/may/14/should-i-worry-about-         how-long-i-spend-sitting-down

Solloway et al (2016). An evidence map of the effect of Tai Chi on health outcomes. Systematic        Reviews, (5)126.

Start, A.R., Allard, Y., Adler, A., & Toblin, R,. (2019). Predicting suicide ideation in the military: the     independent role of aggression. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 49(2).

Twemlow, S.T., Sacco, F.C., & Fonagy, P. (2008). Embodying the mind: movement as a container for destructive aggression.American Journal of Psychotherapy, 62(1).

van der Kolk, B. (2015). The Body Keeps The Score. Penguin

Winnicott, D.W. (1984). The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment. Routledge

Winnicott, D.W. (1990a). Delinquency as a Sign of Hope. In Home is Where We Start From.      Penguin

Winnicott, D.W. (1990b). Aggression, Guilt and Reparation. In Home is Where We Start From. Penguin

Winnicott, D.W. (1994). Hate in the counter-transference. Journal of Psychotherapy Practice &         Research, 3(4), 350–356.

Winnicott, D.W. (2005). The use of an object through relating and identifications. In Playing and       Reality. Routledge

Winnicott, D.W. (2006). The family affected by depressive illness. In The Family and Individual Development. Routledge

Winnicott, D.W. (2021a). Aspects of juvenile delinquency. In The Child, the Family and the Outside     World. Penguin

Winnicott, D.W. (2021b). The roots of aggression. In The Child, the Family and the Outside      World. Penguin

Watts, A. (2002). What is Tao? New World Library

Watts, A. (2003). Become What You Are. Shambhala

Weiser, M., Kutz, I., Jacobson Kutz, S., & Weiser, D. (1995). Psychotherapeutic aspects of the   martial arts. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 49(1).

Yakeley, J, & Meloy, J.R. (2012). Understanding violence: does psychoanalytic thinking matter?         Aggression and Violent Behavior, 17, 229–239. DOI:10.1016/j.avb.2012.02.006

Zheng, Y., Zhou, Y., & Lai, Q. (2015). Effects of twenty-four move shadow boxing combined with       psychosomatic relaxation on depression and anxiety in patients with type-2 diabetes. Psychiatria Danubina, 27(2), 174-179.

Zuckerman, J.R. (2019). Nasty Women: Toward a new narrative on female aggression.   Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 55(3), 214-251, DOI: 10.1080/00107530.2019.1637392